RSS Feeds NGN on Facebook NGN on Twitter NGN on YouTube
Wednesday April 2, 2025
Header logo

California video game law struck down

Banning the sale of violent games to minors is a violation of free speech, justices say

Posted on
The Supreme Court ended its term with a vigorous defense of free speech, striking down a California law that banned sales of violent video games to minors and effectively shielding the entertainment industry from any government effort to limit violent content, reports LA Times.

"Like books, plays and movies, video games communicate ideas," said Justice Antonin Scalia in his majority opinion Monday. And he said there was "no tradition in this country of specially restricting children's access to depictions of violence. … Grimm's Fairy Tales, for example, are grim indeed."

The decision, coming on the term's last day, highlights a consistent theme of the high court under Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr.: Freedom of speech is almost always a winner, even if the context is unusual.

In Monday's decision in the case of Brown vs. Entertainment Merchants Assn., a 7-2 majority voted against California's law, but the justices were divided 5 to 4 over whether violence in the media could ever be regulated to protect children.

The video game law passed the Legislature in 2005. It would have imposed a $1,000 fine on those who sold or rented a video game to someone under 18 that featured the "killing, maiming, dismembering or sexual assaulting" of a human image and "appeals to deviant or morbid interest." Before the law could take effect, the gaming industry sued, and judges put the law on hold.

Advocates for control of the media were disappointed. "This ruling replaces the authority of parents with the economic interests of the video game industry," said Tim Winter, president of the Parents Television Council in Los Angeles. "With no fear of any consequence for violating the video game industry's own age restriction guidelines, retailers can now openly, brazenly sell games with unspeakable violence and adult content even to the youngest of children."

The full details on the story can be found in the original article at
LA Times.

Comments
Screens







Online
There are currently 0 members and 267 guests on the website right now.
Who's On?
Activity in the past 10 minutes:
  • 267 guests
Best News this Month
Rainbow Six Siege X launches this summer
Major free update plans to revamp the multiplayer tactical shooter, as it goes free to play

Posted 20 days ago
Free PlayStation Plus games for April 2025
Action and horror adventure offered next month
7 days ago
Killing Floor 3 delayed
A last second decision to change the launch plans of shooter
26 days ago
Death Stranding 2 out in June
Special editions of adventure game sequel announced
24 days ago
Indiana Jones and the Great Circle coming to PS5 in April
Action game coming to new platform soon
9 days ago
Latest Comments
Metroid Prime 4: Beyond - Nintendo Direct Trailer...
Mar 29, 2025 by bartd
surely it will be cross-lauch with Switch 2, but nice of...
Monaco 2 out in April
Mar 27, 2025 by JamesJay
definitely feels like one of those sequels that are way...
Avowed Review
Mar 18, 2025 by Beyu
I like Obsidian but I feel like their RPGs have gotten...
Free PlayStation Plus games for March 2025
Mar 5, 2025 by graim
to offer dragon age already is crazy!
Action game Saros announced
Feb 15, 2025 by JamesJay
i liked Returnal and am surprised they are changing the...
New Game Network NGN Facebook NGN Twitter NGN Youtube NGN RSS