RSS Feeds NGN on Facebook NGN on Twitter NGN on YouTube
Welcome, Guest. Login | Register | PW? ]
Header logo
  1. Index
  2. » Articles
  3. » Reviews
  4. » Guardians of Middle-earth

Guardians of Middle-earth Review

A console-based MOBA set in Middle Earth? It's better than you'd think.

Posted by on

While the core gameplay is strong, none of it matters without solid online matchmaking and game hosting. At launch, Guardians was crippled by a number of problems, particularly horrendous matchmaking issues that could leave you stranded in the match queue for 2 minutes or 20. In the weeks since, the matchmaking issues have been mostly alleviated but sadly the game’s crippling lag is still commonplace. In majority of the matches I played, character hitching and constant, crippling lag was a major factor in every single battle, something that made me want to throw my controller against the wall in frustration. MOBAs are all about precision. This is especially the case with a very twitch-heavy game like Guardians in which player skill feels far more important than player knowledge (the lack of gear, less focus on builds, etc). While I was still able to enjoy the game overall (mostly due to the fact that most of the matches tend to be fairly one sided after the first few moments and encounters), the lag is something that needs to be addressed if it isn’t being already. Without it, Guardians would be a considerably better game than it is now.

Guardians of Middle-earth

Guardians of Middle Earth is a solid MOBA and a strong case for the genre on consoles. The controllers work well, so well that it felt a bit like a step backward when I sat down to play a match in DOTA 2 with my mouse and keyboard. From a presentation standpoint, the game is adequate with some impressive character designs. The biggest things holding Guardians back from greatness is its unfortunate technical and community issues. When the majority of games played contain nearly constant hitching and lag, it can be impossible to execute the necessary twitch maneuvers anywhere near as well as you’d like. The game’s community is a bit hard to judge at this point, but it never stood apart from the typical MOBA crowd, frustrating and childish whiners that seem to constantly blame anyone but themselves. Thankfully without a keyboard attached to the machine, whining is kept to a minimum most of the time.

Guardians of Middle-earth

If you are a fan of the genre like myself, that I would recommend Guardians of Middle Earth, especially if you are looking for a game type you enjoy able to be experienced in a new way. If the genre has turned you off elsewhere, Guardians and its community certainly won’t change your mind. Lastly for those of you without any MOBA experience, Guardians could be a good game to jump in on as the removal or simplification of many of the genre’s complicated systems makes for a more straight forward game.

Our ratings for Guardians of Middle-earth on Xbox 360 out of 100 (Ratings FAQ)
Presentation
86
Following the visual style established in the film trilogy, the game looks great even if itís a bit uneven
Gameplay
82
By removing most of the gear, items and focusing on twitch, area-based attacks, the game focuses on player skill over knowledge of the meta-game
Single Player
62
Bot matches are good for those new to the genre but donít provide much interest beyond the first few training sessions
Multiplayer
86
A solid core game focusing on skilled game play above all else with a few apparent balancing issues
Performance
65
Visual glitches, lag and overall weirdness are all still somewhat commonplace
Overall
76
Guardians of Middle Earth is a strong case for MOBAs on console but technical issues limit the fun
Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus
Guardians of Middle-earth
Guardians of Middle-earth box art Platform:
Xbox 360
Our Review of Guardians of Middle-earth
76%
Good
The Verdict:
Game Ranking
Guardians of Middle-earth is ranked #695 out of 1666 total reviewed games. It is ranked #77 out of 145 games reviewed in 2012.
694. Wonderbook: Book of Spells
PlayStation 3
695. Guardians of Middle-earth
696. MotoGP 13
PC
Related Games
Middle-earth: Shadow of War Middle-earth: Shadow of War
Platform: PlayStation 4
Released: October 2017
Developer: Monolith Productions
Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor
Platform: PlayStation 4
Released: September 2014
Developer: Monolith Productions
Gotham City Impostors Gotham City Impostors
Platform: PC
Released: February 2012
Developer: Monolith Productions
F.E.A.R. 2: Project Origin F.E.A.R. 2: Project Origin
Platform: PC
Released: February 2009
Developer: Monolith Productions
F.E.A.R. F.E.A.R.
Platform: PC
Released: October 2005
Developer: Monolith Productions
Screenshots

Guardians of Middle-earth
12 images added Jan 18, 2013 16:24
Advertisement ▼
New Game Network NGN Facebook NGN Twitter NGN Youtube NGN RSS