RSS Feeds NGN on Facebook NGN on Twitter NGN on YouTube
Welcome, Guest. Login | Register | PW? ]
Header logo

Ambiguous Exposition: Mass Effect 3 and Journey


A look at the juxtaposition of the narrative designs found in two recent releases

Posted by Matthew Sawrey (matski53) on Mar 28, 2012 - 11:23pm EST (Mar 28, 2012 23:23)

Yet within this constraint Thatgamecompany are able to exhibit a cinematic sense of control over what emotion any moment in Journey will provoke – going as far as ripping control away from your thumbs at times, to be concentrated on a particularly beautiful angle. This design choice makes a lot of sense when you consider the fact that Jenova Chen and his team begin a development process by deciding on the emotions they want to portray before anyone even suggests a mechanic.

The one area in Journey that Thatgamecompany doesn’t take complete control over is the co-operative multiplayer. Its portrayal of companionship may be an extremely limited affair with nothing but your personal symbol and sounds to communicate. Yet the reduction of interaction to such a simplistic form removes so many complicating barriers and boundaries. You may not know the detailed history of your companion as you would of Wrex in Mass Effect, but I found that most everyone I came across was willing to share this Journey with me, evoking the childlike joy of friendship free of preconceptions.
 
Journey PS3

The image of 2 wanderers in a lonely desert is a striking one to be sure, and if a picture can paint a thousand words, then Journey’s aesthetic paints a thousand pictures. Drawn with a slightly ethereal and otherworldly presence, Journey is constructed from hazy yet simplistic cell shading that adds to the overall ambiguity of its structure and narrative design. Mass Effect 3 on the other hand is an unflinchingly stark visual depiction of a universe at war. All cold metallic space stations, colorfully incandescent nebula’s, and lens flare saturated destroyed cityscapes. Its visuals are as serious as its sombre plot.

Each game’s visual depiction serves to aid their method of storytelling, just as the protagonists of each adventure do. Journey’s wanderer may be expressionless, but it is essentially a puppet, a cypher like Link or Gordon Freeman through which the player can experience the freezing blizzards of a harsh mountain, or the gleeful joy of sand surfing. Commander Shepard, on the other hand, is very much your own personalized avatar. Make it male, make it female, make it look like you, choose your own backstory, punch the journalist, don’t punch the journalist. It truly is up to you.

“This war will affect all of us! The fate of every organic species in the galaxy depends upon us putting aside out differences, pulling together as a team, and fighting the Reapers. Are you with me?”
 
Journey PS3

Mass Effect 3 is a Pokedex of detail, explaining every last point of intrigue, yet granting a level of personalization to its narrative that fosters investment. Whereas, like that monolithic slab in the opening scene of "2001: A Space Odyssey," Journey is a grand rigid structure of intrigue that has the power to illicit wonderful and provocative thoughts and ideas in the minds of those willing to dream along with its ambiguity. So where one is suggestive, the other is explanative. Where one starves you of detail and invites you to imagine, the other aims to saturate your curiosity with information and exposition. Where one strives towards personalization, the other presents a pre-designed experience, consistently engineering images that tug on your emotional heartstrings.

I would not be so arrogant as to suggest that one style of storytelling is better than the other. What you are emotionally affected by is a hugely personal and subjective, dependent upon many extrinsic and intrinsic factors. All I know is that one of these games truly moved me and the other simply gave me the freedom to move it, which speaks volumes of the narrative potential within gaming today.
 

Interaction
Share
Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus
SpectralShock - 2 days ago
Next up, the big show - E3 in June!
SpectralShock - 8 days ago
PAX East this weekend
Captain_Mark87 - 33 days ago
Titanfall has eaten all my spare time!!!
SpectralShock - 43 days ago
Lots of reviews coming this and next week!
with_teeth26 - 48 days ago
The first great challenge of Dark Souls 2 is determining the PC release date
Captain_Mark87 - 56 days ago
Titanfall was super fun. Strider review coming at you soon.
NEW SHOUT
You must login to post in the shoutbox.
Most viewed this Month

Yaiba: Ninja Gaiden Z Review
Posted 20 days ago by SpectralShock

Metal Gear Solid V: Ground Zeroe...
Posted 17 days ago by Al-man

Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 2 R...
Posted 30 days ago by Nechrol

Titanfall Review
Posted 31 days ago by MattPorter

Infamous: Second Son Review
Posted 16 days ago by SpectralShock

Rambo: The Video Game Review
Posted 26 days ago by SpectralShock

Tower of Guns Review
Posted 28 days ago by Quill

Deus Ex: The Fall Review
Posted 24 days ago by Quill

Ether One Review
Posted 14 days ago by Quill
Last 3 Months Platform
X360
1. Dragon Ball Z: Battle ...
Type: Review
Author: Captain_Mark87

X360
2. Child of Light Preview...
Preview


X360
4. Fable Anniversary Review
Review




PC
8. Thief Review
Review

X360
9. South Park: The Stick ...
Review

PC
10. The Elder Scrolls Onli...
Preview
Latest Comments
Photo mode added to...
Apr 17, 2014 by Manny
good on them to make so many...
Manny

Watch Dogs - PC...
Apr 16, 2014 by JamesJay
Hopefully its well...
JamesJay

Child of Light Preview...
Apr 16, 2014 by Austin Clark
Really looking forward to Child...
Austin Clark

PVZ Garden Warfare...
Apr 15, 2014 by Jayro
free is always welcome
Jayro

Final Fantasy XIV: A...
Apr 15, 2014 by Austin Clark
I'm really looking forward to...
Austin Clark

Advertisement ▼
pfooter
Advertisement ▼