RSS Feeds NGN on Facebook NGN on Twitter NGN on YouTube
Welcome, Guest. Login | Register | PW? ]
Header logo

Mass Effect 2 Review

Improved combat, sped up pacing and pared-down role playing elements make Mass Effect 2 a Sci-fi epic for the masses

Posted by (with_teeth26) on

These days it seems that an overwhelming number of major releases are, in one way or another, sequels. Most fit neatly into a pre-established IP, but rarely provide a direct continuation of the events of previous games in the series. Not only does Mass Effect 2 break this trend by providing a direct continuation of the events of Mass Effect 1, it takes it one step further by allowing the specific actions you took in first game to affect the way things play out in the second. Mass Effect 2 is the first game to allow you to carry over your save games, and at the same time decisions from the first game, into the sequel, creating an experience which will in all likelihood by a bit different for everyone.

Mass Effect 2
Talking to your crew is often rewarding - occasionally hilarious

This carrying-over of save games is by itself a great feature, but does not really affect how good Mass Effect 2 is quality wise. Luckily Bioware saw to it that pretty much all the major problems of the excellent but flawed original were dealt with – fixed, overhauled or removed completely. As a result, Mass Effect 2 feels very different from the original, the pacing has been jacked up, the combat feels like it belongs in a high quality third-person shooter, and the epic overarching story of Mass Effect 1 has been superseded by a dark, gritty character driven tale that is very enjoyable in its own way. It doesn’t feel like the epic space opera we saw two years ago, but rather a deep, well paced and polished third person shooter with some role playing elements which enhance the experience. Mass Effect 2 is not, nor is it trying to be, a traditional RPG like Dragon Age, and making this realization is imperative if you want to enjoy this game to its full potential. ME 2 is a shooter first and foremost, and a Role-Playing game second.

Thankfully, Mass Effect 2 works very well as a shooter. While the cover system, basic squad commands and pause menu remain basically the same as those found in Mass Effect 1, the actual gunplay and enemy a.i. is much better. The gunplay in particular feels much closer to what you would find in a third person shooter like Gears of War, recoil, damage, and accuracy and range all need to be taken into account when firing a weapon. The overheating system found in ME 1 has been replaced with a more conventional ammunition or ‘thermal clip’ system, where enemies drop ammo after they are killed. You also have the opportunity to mod your ammo, depending on what type of enemy you are fighting. You no longer get experience for killing enemies, which some may dislike, but once you get used to the new system its works very well.

Mass Effect 2
Subject Zero is as crazy as she looks

One of the biggest problems with the original Mass Effect’s combat was the friendly and enemy artificial intelligence. One of the bugs from Mass Effect 1 that is still present in the sequel is the path finding issues of your squad mates. They will occasionally walk into the open during a firefight, or climb on top of cover instead of hiding behind it. Luckily the enemy A.I. has been mostly fixed – in the original game, most baddies would simply charge at you, making combat often confusing and frustrating. Your opponents still aren’t the brightest, but they are much less problematic this time around, they will use cover and try to flank you, which make the shootouts much more enjoyable. There are still a few enemies that try to advance on you, but this is not a bad thing since it forces you to change your tactics – and the combat is much more tactical. Your powers are much more useful this time around and have more clearly defined effects – some are good against armour, some against shields, some only work against organic enemies – you have to change the way you play depending on which class you are, which abilities your squad mates have, and which enemies you are fighting.

In Mass Effect 1, all the classes felt fairly similar, and most of the time you would end up using 1 weapon for most of the game and maybe one or two powers. ME 2’s classes are more clearly defined, and depending on your choice you will have to change the way you play. While ME 1 allowed you to use all weapons in all classes but only let you train for 1 or two types of weapons, ME 2 only lets you use the weapons your class specializes in – although there are no longer ways to train in weapon proficiency.

Mass Effect 2
Only Shepard had the foresight to wear a helmet that day

Instead of training to become better with armour or weapons, you will find upgrades for them lying about, or you can buy them at various places throughout the game. Once you find the upgrade, you can’t immediately use it. You first need to return to the Normandy, which again is your ‘base’ in ME 2, and research the upgrade. It doesn’t end there – to research the upgrade, you need to have enough of 1 of 5 kinds of ore, which you obtain in two ways. Small amounts of ore are scattered throughout the game, but if you want to get all the upgrades you find, or at least the majority of them, you will need to spend a substantial amount of time in a rather dull but compulsively addicting mining mini game, where you scan a planet for ore and launch probes to extract it. This mini game replaces the planet exploration bits in Mass Effect 1, which is a welcome change because of how poor the Mako handling was, although you will occasionally find ‘anomalies’ in your scanning, at which point you can land and check things out.

Also gone is the inventory system which caused so much grief and frustration. In its place is a more shooter-like pre-mission squad load out screen, where you choose which weapons which squad members will use. Unlike Mass Effect 1, where there were a lot of different guns that all had the same basic model and feel but different stats, you will only find two or three different guns in each category, they are fairly different from each other, especially the new heavy weapons, but the stats have also been removed, so you don’t know the specific advantages of each weapon. It would seem that weapon stats could have easily been integrated into the new weapon-locker system, since when you get upgrades such as damage upgrades it will give you a percent increase, but you don’t know what that increase is on top of. Still, the new weapon locker system is a lot more intuitive than the awkward inventory management of ME 1, and serves to help the game rather than hinder it. The new armour system is similar to the new weapon system – gone are the stats, instead you can upgrade specific parts of it, and even customize the appearance of your armour. This ‘streamlined’ approach to your equipment may disappoint those in search of more traditional looting, but it does serve to simplify the experience and keep you focused on the combat and the dialogue.

Mass Effect 2
Armor: Check. Guns: Check. Umbrella - oh dear

Once you complete the introductory quests, which are very cinematic and pull you into the game from the start, the structure of the campaign becomes fairly formulaic. You have to recruit a number of squad members, and if you wish to gain their loyalty you must complete one quest for each of them. These loyalty quests are optional, but should be completed because they are just as well done as the main story missions, and will unlock the most powerful abilities of your squad members. Mass Effect had fewer but much longer missions, while ME 2 will take you to a great variety of locations in shorter but faster paced missions, almost all of which are very well done. This time around it is very easy to go off and do side quests, and unlike those in the original they are, for the most part, well worth doing. While the first game could be completed in 12-15 hours due to the lack of side quests that were worth doing, an average play through of Mass Effect 2 should take 20-30 hours, with more thorough playthroughs pushing 40 hours, thanks to the great side quests that are seamlessly integrated into the experience.

The story in Mass Effect 2 is character driven, and fortunately the game is full of interesting characters with wildly varying personalities. Being a Bioware game, you will end up spending a good portion of your time in dialogue sequences, and while the basic structure of them is unchanged from Mass Effect 1, there are a few minor changes. The most notable of which is the opportunity to interfere with either a paragon or renegade action within a dialogue sequence, these usually entail stopping someone from shooting someone else, or punching someone in the face, depending on the situation. The dialogue is also more natural, characters move around instead of standing rigidly in one spot, and the writing is just as good as ever.

Mass Effect 2
The Normandy is now tricked out with mining equipment

Mass Effect 1 on the PC suffered from a number of technical issues, and thankfully all of these have been fixed in the sequel. I experience no crashing, frame rate issues, or instability of any kind in my 25 hour play through, the texture pop in that plagued the first game is nowhere to be seen. Visually the game is fairly impressive, no game can match the series for cinematic presentation, and most interior environments are stunningly beautiful with an intense colour palette and vibrant lighting effects. There are a few dodgy textures scattered here and there, most noticeably the clothing of non-important characters, but the result of this is that the game runs extremely well on less than cutting edge hardware. The great music of the original is back, with a few additions such as orchestral bits, the voice acting is phenomenal, and perhaps the best of any Bioware game to date, and adds to the game in a substantial way. The sound design has been improved as well, weapons sound great, and there is a huge amount of detail in the audio which serves to further immerse you in the world of Mass Effect.

Overall Mass Effect 2 is a highly successful sequel that takes the series in a direction some will hate and some will love. The game is more focused than its predecessor, which straddled the line between shooter and RPG, and as a result feels much more like a shooter than a Role Playing Game. As a RPG Mass Effect 2 leaves much to be desired, but seen as a shooter with light role playing elements it shines, and leaves you wondering how you will pass the time until the final game in the epic trilogy is released.

Our ratings for Mass Effect 2 on PC out of 100 (see how we rate)
Presentation
90
Great cinematic presentation with good visuals, appropriate music, outstanding voice acting, some dodgy textures.
Gameplay
87
Combat is greatly improved, the dialogue sequences are as cinematic and enjoyable as ever, some A.I. path finding issues and minor bugs, overabundance of mini games.
Single Player
89
Both longer and better paced than the original, much improved side quests, very enjoyable character driven story.
Multiplayer
NR
None
Performance
(Show PC Specs)
CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo e7200 @ 3.1ghz
GPU: Powercolor Radeon HD 5850 PCS+
RAM: 4GB DDR2
OS: Windows 7 Ultimate 64 bit
PC Specs

90
Excellent frame rates on aging hardware, no crashing or instability to speak of.
Overall
89
As long as you see Mass Effect 2 as a shooter first and foremost, it is an amazing experience that improves on the original in many ways and sets up the third Mass Effect nicely.
Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus
Post Comment
You may not post comments as a guest. Please register or login to your account.
Username:
Password:
Create a new account?
Forgot your password?
#7 Feb 9, 2010 18:20:00 (Feb 9, 2010 18:20)

sirdesmond
Truthfully as much of a frustration as the controls on the MAKO were in ME1, I really miss the ability to actively explore the different planets. I had a ton of fun experiencing the mystery of searching planets for minerals, crash debris, or hidden outposts.
#6 Feb 8, 2010 21:13:16 (Feb 8, 2010 21:13)

nutcrackr
Every story quest and squad member find and loyalty quest were great. So I think you definitely did get more good quests in ME2. Pretty much the rest of the quests were pretty poor. I guess its whether you consider the squad member quests side quests or not. They are integral to the game and story - but not required.
 
#5 Feb 8, 2010 20:24:26 (Feb 8, 2010 20:24)

with_teeth26
 @ all who think the side quests are better in ME 1: Consider this, ME 1 had about 12 hours of quests that were actually carefully scripted and put together. There were some cool side quests at The Citadel, but other than that the vast majority were cut and paste side quests that had you going to the same outpost on some random planet. There were a few exceptions, but most of them were pretty bad.
 
ME 2 had around 20 hours of quality, scripted quests, and while those side quests other than the loyalty ones were no better, if not worse, than those in ME 1, there were more of the high caliber side quests in ME 2. 
 
 
#4 Feb 8, 2010 15:58:35 (Feb 8, 2010 15:58)

kamikaziechameleon
Two biggest complaints though are the implimentation of romance, its to identical to the first game.  And that mind numbing mining game.
#3 Feb 8, 2010 15:55:56 (Feb 8, 2010 15:55)

kamikaziechameleon
 Yeah I felt the game was great at telling story, but the story this time around wasn't as creative or surprising.  They pretty much tell you what will happen in the first hour of the game.  The marketing removed every cool moment or suprise from the game, you see every squad member in the prerelease trailors and have their motives spelled out for you.
Great game overall.
#2 Feb 8, 2010 00:05:20 (Feb 8, 2010 00:05)

SpectralShock
I sorta agree, I think the side missions in the original were at least less predictable - you didn't know where you'd find one. In ME2 you already know each squad member has a side mission you must complete to earn their trust, sorta takes any anticipation out of me.
#1 Feb 7, 2010 10:40:22 (Feb 7, 2010 10:40)

DoomGiverIV
I have to say this is a pretty spot on review. Really the only thing i would disagree with is your comment about the side quests. Excluding the ones for your teammates i felt the side quests in ME2 were not as good as ME1 but this is a minor complaint since let's be honest in both games it's really about the main story and interacting with its characters.
Mass Effect 2
Mass Effect 2 box art Platform:
PC
Our Review of Mass Effect 2
89%
Great
The Verdict:
Game Ranking
Mass Effect 2 is ranked #32 out of 1,213 total reviewed games.
32. Mass Effect 2
33. God of War III
PlayStation 3
Related Games
Anthem Anthem
Platform: PC
Coming: December 2018
Developer: BioWare
Mass Effect: Andromeda Mass Effect: Andromeda
Platform: PC
Released: March 2017
Developer: BioWare Montreal
Dragon Age: Inquisition Dragon Age: Inquisition
Platform: PC
Released: November 2014
Developer: BioWare
Mass Effect 3 Mass Effect 3
Platform: PC
Released: March 2012
Developer: BioWare
Star Wars: The Old Republic Star Wars: The Old Republic
Platform: PC
Released: December 2011
Developer: BioWare
Dragon Age 2 Dragon Age 2
Platform: PC
Released: March 2011
Developer: BioWare
Screenshots

Mass Effect 2
17 images added Feb 6, 2010 17:08
Videos
Mass Effect 2 - Gamescom 09
Posted: Aug 19, 2009 05:22
Mass Effect 2 - "Subject Zero" Trailer
Posted: Sep 29, 2009 20:21
Dirty Dozen Extended
Posted: Jan 5, 2010 09:37
Advertisement ▼
New Game Network NGN Facebook NGN Twitter NGN Youtube NGN RSS